Chronotope’s avatarChronotope’s Twitter Archive—№ 90,380

                                                                                                1. Medium will fail to on-board & keep pubs from now until eternity for a simple reason: as a VC funded startup it values hype more than profit
                                                                                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                                B/c it values hype over profit, every move to make money is afterthought, its least innovative features. Chronotope/844941681359310848
                                                                                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                              Medium's basic premise as a company is 'what if tech solves publishing, because publishers are stupid' Chronotope/817750258251956224
                                                                                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                            It's basic design sense was 'design is stupid, what if tech solved design?' which is dumb and ends up with Chronotope/844946787274252289
                                                                                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                          It's basic pitch is 'what if we gave writers confidential closed source tech instead of money?' Chronotope/844944178043895809
                                                                                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                        Of course publishers are leaving Medium. It's because, philosophically, Medium doesn't believe that publishers should A. exist & B. profit.
                                                                                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                      Medium won't prioritize the tools publishers need because for-profit writing organizations are inimical to the model axios.com/publishers-flee-medium-amid-business-model-changes-2440471520.html
                                                                                      OpenGraph image for axios.com/publishers-flee-medium-amid-business-model-changes-2440471520.html
                                                                                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                    It's just like Uber briefly having a Taxi booking function. It won't work well because Taxis and Ubers cannot coexist in Uber's biz model.
                                                                                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                  By the same measure, the Medium business model isn't compatible with publishing companies exceeding one employee.
                                                                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                                The irony here for such a 'culture' focused business field is that Medium shares no values with publishers, thus: Chronotope/873709551618596865
                                                                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                              VCs value hype over profitability, so Medium gets money by releasing stunt features w/no intention of follow up Chronotope/817046256228909057
                                                                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                            Also, b/c Medium, like many of the post-FB startups, wants to create it's own private internet, its publishers waved goodbye to SEO. PSMag:
                                                                            oh my god twitter doesn’t include alt text from images in their API
                                                                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                          Even with PSMag paying for traffic it never reached it's pre-Medium search footprint and will have a hard time getting it back.
                                                                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                        Because Medium wanted hype, it likely paid for publishers to come on. But in long term it won't have been worth it. wfederman/795627673821315073
                                                                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                      For Medium strong good hype makes them profitable & bad barely hurts them, because that's the VC model. Remember?: hblodget/701927661623517184
                                                                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                    The Ringer left on May 30th. No one is reporting 'Big loss for Medium, they lost The Ringer' because that's not how VC-funded startups work.
                                                                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                  They raise money on hype and if someone leaves the platform, they just "didn't get it" or "weren't patient enough" or "bad partners".
                                                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                                Medium wants a Facebook-style closed-garden in which individual writers = dependent contractors. Publishers were foolish to trust them.
                                                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                              And chasing the theoretical and entirely temporary money that Medium offered initially was bad b/c it won't be enough to cover the losses:
                                                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                            Publishers who hopped on and off of Medium will have to rebuild infrastructure, find previously fired engineers, unbreak SEO...
                                                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                          They will have intangible losses like Medium's insulation and incomparability with Facebook, broken backlinks, and confused readers...
                                                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                        And even if they started on Medium, the cost of building out a new site and running the complicated transfer of content will be nasty.
                                                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                      Especially since last I checked, Medium's content export is crap TopLeftBrick/752534361392676864
                                                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                    & will the theoretical up-tick in engagement on Medium (if you even had it Chronotope/818499314154635271 ) carry over after you leave the network?
                                                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                  Nope, because network effect of being on Medium will stay on Medium. That's why they didn't give a shit, they thought that locked pubs in.
                                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                Being on Medium was, is, and will always be, bad for publishers. End of Story.
                                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                            Ev will say literally anything for press attention, which in the VC economy == money MattSaccaro/910546494578622465
                                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                          Medium is not trustworthy even when it promises to pay people. StuHorvath/874997693696925697
                                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                        Medium no longer has the network effect required to distinguish it from any other web publisher in a meaningful way. Chronotope/896090431099879425
                                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                      Medium doesn't care about its partners Chronotope/817046256228909057
                                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                    Medium has no original ideas anymore it's just Hype and VC funding Chronotope/874977909890568193
                                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                  Latest Medium pivot is about is the new instability in display ads making standard publishing easier to disrupt Chronotope/817750258251956224
                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                If Ev is talking to you about 'being an editor' on his 'Thought Catalog for VC Buddies' it is your moral imperative to turn that job down.
                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                              He has made very clear he has no interest in creating a platform that supports writing as an art or journalism as a societal need.
                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                            At this point Medium is exploitative in every possible way. Of its writers. Of the economy in which it lives. Of the publishing industry.
                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                          Stop letting Ev walk around and use your publications to push out his latest pivot BS. Be critical and ask critical questions!
                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                        When Ev is coming into your traditional media publication he *needs you* to keep up the fantasy bubble that keeps Medium afloat.
                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                      This is the ultimate irony: Ev & Medium are dependent on traditional media platforms to push their attempt to destroy those platforms.
                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                    Ev thinks he's smartest man in the room but learns nothing from others. So he'll keep making stupid mistakes. Don't let him get away w/it.
                    oh my god twitter doesn’t include alt text from images in their API
                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                  Never stops being true: Chronotope/981597655229976576
              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                “We’ve had an arrangement with them for two years. I’m not saying they don’t have a right to break it. We’ve been scaling back, trying to get people to other platforms anyway. But it’d be nice to have more of a heads up.” niemanlab.org/2018/05/medium-abruptly-cancels-the-membership-programs-of-its-21-remaining-publisher-partners/
            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
              “Meanwhile, we’re trying to make a living here. We’re cool with experimenting. But this is been an unbelievable blow. Could we have a better metaphor for the way Silicon Valley considers local journalism?” niemanlab.org/2018/05/medium-abruptly-cancels-the-membership-programs-of-its-21-remaining-publisher-partners/
          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
            Just remember that by acting as his unabashed PR firm, where he arranged an article explicitly with this timing, The New York Times is complicit in Ev and Medium's fundamentally disrespectful execution in regards to journalism. nytimes.com/2018/05/09/business/ev-williams-twitter-medium.html
            OpenGraph image for nytimes.com/2018/05/09/business/ev-williams-twitter-medium.html
        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
          Medium's entire fundamental model and approach is inimical to journalism and whenever they pivot in a direction that looks good for publications it's just for the good PR. It's never an honest turn. Remember that if you are a tech/media journalist next time you cover them.
      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
        Ev thinks he's so smart that he is going to tap into the secret to Save Journalism that everyone around him who has been working on and in the industry longer is just too dumb to figure out. He will *never* respect your publication.
    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
      And because he doesn't respect people who have been working on *this very problem*, because he refuses to believe anyone could be as smart or smarter than him, he will never ever *ever* solve the problems of the journalism business. Chronotope/994314341498408960
  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
    Medium *might* be a cool product. Maybe. But as a business its leader will never do anything but leave the debris of others who dare to try and make a living in its wake. j_zimms/994286919528996864
    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
      Medium will never be good for writing or publishing or every creative endeavor because not only does Ev not respect creativities, but his business models all focus on why their work is--and can be made--as close to zero value as possible. jayasax/994252016129101824
      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
        Exactly. It can't help anyone else make money because as a VC-funded startup it's incentivised to just always get more press, continue to pivot, and shrink expenses. petersterne/994632639138148352
        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
          Medium is bad. Ev will not solve publishing, much less the internet. But he definitely will never be the person who helps creative people get paid because he has no respect for what they do. Chronotope/903292782286176256
          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
            And he telegraphs it *all the time* Chronotope/874977909890568193
            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                      So stop giving Medium and Ev the good PR they need to CONTINUALLY pull this crap! Chronotope/817046256228909057
                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                        Stop reporting on Ev. Instead, report on all the publications he's screwed over since he started Medium. Did they recover? What does their leadership have to say about Medium now a year after they left?
                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                          How did this approach make editing difficult? Maintaining publishing standards? Raising money? What was the transfer off Medium like? How does this effect their bottom line, profit or non-profit?
                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                            Medium and Ev aren't helping anyone. So instead write the more interesting story that isn't gross fawning over some tech entrepreneur. Write the story about the people Medium *hurts*.
                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                              Write this story instead of heaping praise on an undeserving Ev. HalimahMarcus/994297053491744768?s=19
                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                Medium reinvents blogger dot com, thus proving once and for all they don't have ideas, don't know what they're doing, and really really aren't for publishers. help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003053487-Custom-Domains-service-deprecation
                                OpenGraph image for help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003053487-Custom-Domains-service-deprecation
                                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                  Ev doesn't give a shit about your publication. He never ever did. Chronotope/994939666477584385
                                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                    Medium will never be compatible with publishers or publications. Chronotope/1375078793019277316?s=19
                                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                      Multi author publications are not among Ev's target users, they get were and never will be: "To Williams, colleagues say, Medium is first and foremost a technology product." theverge.com/2021/3/24/22349175/medium-layoffs-union-evan-williams-blogger-twitter-subscription
                                      OpenGraph image for theverge.com/2021/3/24/22349175/medium-layoffs-union-evan-williams-blogger-twitter-subscription
                                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                        A problem w/the SV mindset is: they think they're building for an inevitable future, but actually they're creating a future as they envision. B/c of the friction between beliefs and reality, they see users who don't confirm to the founder's approach as aberrations, not use cases.
                                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                          Medium will never be good at multi author organized publications for the same reason Facebook will never be good at moderation... their founders see those behaviors as aberrations that will be inevitably ended by the sweep of The Future, not use cases to be addressed.
                                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                            Medium is bad and it literally cannot stop itself from being bad: timmaughan/1420808936555487238
                                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                              Medium is not for writers, publishers, or creative people in general. They're just cogs in Medium's badly designed machine. lillydancyger/1420761507118260224
                                              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                Medium has always been very very upfront about the fact that their entire model is reliant on them getting free content from writers for Medium to do with whatever they please. Chronotope/844944178043895809
                                                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                  This thread started 4 years ago and Medium keeps doing exactly the same shitty things over and over and every time it's like "oh my how did this happen to this otherwise fine company" because apparently memory doesn't go further back than three months ago.
                                                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                    The cycle of Medium's BS continues to continue. ow/1471172289496424452?t=H4ZsB-4b7y9oNe6y0Eo9rA&s=19
                                                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                                                      Medium is bad and it continues to be bad. Bad for its writers and bad for the web. Stop using it. Chronotope/1520002196414386181
                                                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope


Search tweets' text