-
Well this is new, 300x250 units from ad exchanges designed to look like Taboola/Outbrain units CC: robleathern
-
Hmmm, selling US car insurance through tons of India economics and tech sites? Seems like a bad investment.
-
In case you were wondering, despite the logos on their shirts those two women aren't the MIT grads disrupting the car insurance industry...
-
The two MIT grads are Seth Birnbaum ( crunchbase.com/person/seth-birnbaum-2#/entity ) and Tomas Revesz ( crunchbase.com/person/tomas-revesz#/entity )
-
Surely the sudden barrage of Outbrain & ad exchange spots w/this ad isn't some crass strategy to juice the numbers before raising capital?
-
Gee, I hope Stratim Capital, Oceanic Partners and T Capital Partners didn't base any their investments off web traffic numbers in any way.
-
Because it sure looks like the ad buy wasn't particularly targeted and therefore is pulling in a lot of likely BS traffic.
-
And the ad placement itself encourages traffic to come in with no knowledge of what they are clicking to.
-
Which means EverQuote seems to be driving a pull of a lot of traffic unlikely to create sales leads. *shrugz*
-
Havvvvve fun selling car insurance to millennials who are decreasingly buying cars. ttfn dudes.
-
I like that they are A/B testing smiling ladies vs frowny ladies. The frowny ladies showed up on an article about harassment, so good call?
-
This is irritating me, so let's keep digging!
-
You'll note none of the things mentioned in the ad prompt are actually here except auto insurance. So this is right on edge of #contentfraud
-
So what is Provide Insurance, besides reportedly awful at service: reviewopedia.com/provide-insurance-com-reviews & ripoffreport.com/r/provide-insurancecom/internet/provide-insurancecom-carprovide-insurancecom-Created-fake-websites-to-promote-Internet-911378
-
EverQuote is an "auto insurance marketplace was named to this year's Inc. 5000" that raised $23M in their B round 7 days ago.
-
EverQuote sure sounds like some sort of insurance company, but it is an insurance marketplace. What that means is unclear.
-
Everquote was launched out of a startup accelerator in Cambridge according to their about page, Cogo Labs
-
So yeah affiliate links, generated off a fake news site, through badly targeted Taboola/Outbrain ads. Oh and an app! everquote.com/everdrive/
-
Oh one other thing! Their dubious app, with 73 review and 5-10k installs on Android and dropping downloads - appannie.com/apps/ios/app/1079104334/ ...
-
They took their data collection, authored a study off of dubious samples and unclear users & got it in HuffPost! huffingtonpost.com/entry/the-most-dangerous-interstates_us_5811ef68e4b0390e69ce51d2
-
And I guess that's how we make money on the internet these days.
-
"Disruption" in action eh?
-
More on the now inescapable LiveSmarterDaily - adspider.io/details/ads/7546697/how-2-mit-grads-are-disrupting-the-auto-insurance-industry
-
So we can now confirm that they started running this ad *right* before they started to raise capital for their B round.
-
Now, the question is, was it only for that? Is this literally to just juice those numbers? Will it be running next month? Time will tell.
-
I gotta wonder, theoretically, what happens if VC invests on fraudulent numbers? Is there even a way to withdraw?
-
I guess MIT was too elitist so now it is 'Boston grads' as noted. aexm/801098888149106688
-
To reiterate, this is a shit company & ad is a lie in at least 3 ways: 1. They aren't disrupting shit. 2. Those two women aren't the grads
-
3. It isn't turning upside down. Yet note the ad design, white background that blends into the site, aping news site style, plain font...
-
This ad is clearly trying to look like a news story on this site and the click-through brings you to a site that looks like a news site...
-
So this is basically fake news running on a real news site. The problem with reader trust isn't on FB, it is on shit like this.
-
We are engaged in the active practice of trying to make it difficult for readers to distinguish truth from bullshit on our own sites.
-
Bullshit fake news-style Everquote ad now showing above the fold in giant block on guardian's website.
-
BTW, now I'm sure the ad buy is not strongly targeted because it showed up in an incognito window on an article about UK education policy.
-
This ad campaign, now on 4th month, specifically targets news websites & is designed to trick readers into clicking it, thinking it is news.
-
It keeps running. No news sites shut it down, despite it being purely designed to trick readers. This is why journalists are losing trust.
-
We invite them on to our pages and present them with a mix of well-designed advertising fakery and mix it in with our own content...
-
And then we in the media have the gall to ask 'why can't readers distinguish fake news from real news?' Because we trained them not to.
-
“Can you trust what’s put out in the digital news ecosystem when you have fake news mixed in?” shar.es/18T08K via lmoses
-
One more version of the Everquote ad for the books: lmoses/809411920306536452
-
Some more detailed thoughts on this: medium.com/@aramzs/the-media-is-a-business-and-journalism-is-a-job-get-it-together-c1ba78a4df95#.p2zk0959q
-
Clearly someone at EverQuote looked at the previous image and yelled "More screens!"
-
Also props to the graphic designer who used drop shadow to hide the cut lines and then blended to try and make it look like they didn't.
-
Holy shit. Look at all the fake websites EverQuote is building. bit.ly/2hqxyHJ webster/813817046039400448
-
At what point, warnings aside, does this become misrepresentation? Intent to deceive? False advertising?
-
Fun stuff, here is EverQuote's Inc. 5000 page, which lists their 2015 revenue at $96.8M inc.com/profile/everquote
-
In light of all these different websites it is worth noting an earlier ver of the ad mis-reported the ad's source Chronotope/791804583253307393
-
You can see that, unlike the other versions of the ad which list EverQuote as the ad's source that ^ one lists "Provide Savings" as sponsor.
-
You know what would be useful? A lawyer who specializes in business or advertising law. Could get some of these legality questions answered.
-
Genuine question: is this someone else operating on behalf of EverQuote? These things do happen. dennishegstad/813862804205637633
-
And low and behold, EverQuote acknowledges that they indeed have purchased and maintain multiple domains i/web/813865963363803136
-
LOL, now other content marketing ads are stealing EverQuote's ad photo. gabedelahaye/814962011041886208
-
It keeps getting larger.
-
And then reporting happens, great work by sonyaellenmann digging deeper into this mattermark.com/everquote-deceptive-advertising/
-
Turns out EverQuote has been scummy for quite some time hlauinfo/816444928914030594
-
.TheAtlantic's article about media being careful what they publish has a huge link to EverQuote's fake news site in the center of it.
-
By the way, I just noticed another lie in this ad. The "small team of data scientists" is, according to LinkedIn, 200 people. So not small.
-
Can't escape EverQuote! profcarroll/819047135723266048
-
Perhaps this new-found semi-honesty is an after effect of sonyaellenmann's coverage of EverQuote's at-best-deceptive behavior?
-
Looks like the EverQuote geo-targeting is vaguely working. quantumdotdot/821797429309833216
-
Everquote ad arrives to split profits with white supremacists. OFH_John/828968149169090560
-
Never stop being shitty EverQuote hlauinfo/830426115823063040
-
Oh look... EverQuote has discovered Instagram aexm/833738376792645632
-
And hey, Everquote thinks it is "brilliant" now webster/833452256150315008
-
The ever changing pitch and a new star "grad" for EverQuote's targeting. robleathern/842010241499766784
-
And yeah, EverQuote continues to call itself brilliant aexm/840941186043019264
-
Everquote's Math Grads at it again robleathern/846929669341437952
-
EverQuote has these multicultural young people so you won't think about their founders being two old white guys robleathern/846932750313504768
-
I think my favorite part of this EverQuote photoshoot is the EverQuote branding on the water bottles robleathern/846932801618272257
-
So, fun times in EverQuote land, despite statements to sonyaellenmann that they were going to shrink their fake site footprint...
-
EverQuote continues to run a number of fake news sites with the same content bit.ly/2hqxyHJ Around 98 of them:
-
Is this illegal? I don't think so. Is this highly unethical? Yeah, yeah, it is.
-
I suppose we can at least be thankful that EverQuote has decreased the number of these sites that look like news sites, but still: yuck.
-
All new EverQuote ads! They seem to have dropped the misleading text about founders at least. aexm/882779603143716865
-
Worth noting how even more non-specific the copy is here. They're just looking for clicks, who cares if you want car insurance or not.
-
"My phone started ringing within minutes of filling out the EverQuote form, and it did not stop ringing for days." linkedin.com/pulse/other-side-quality-leads-avi-ben-hutta
-
And look QuoteWizard has been doing this crap for a year longer than EverQuote. I guess EverQuote isn't so "disruptive" after all?
-
More EverQuote ads for the endless set. shansquared/894645576071081985
-
I guess only the northeast corridor gets the multi ethnic EverQuote ads?
-
Also, looking at the copy, I guess this bunch aren't Harvard grads?
-
Everyone is slowly seeing their EverQuote ads move to the all white people version, it seems. shansquared/920331182746820608
-
Also, no one is wearing EverQuote gear in the photo anymore, interesting. CC: shansquared
-
shansquared Seriously, do they pay anyone at that company or does it all just go to Outbrain and Taboola?