Chronotope’s avatarChronotope’s Twitter Archive—№ 75,595

                  1. The problem isn't that social media provides us with tools of mass amplification. The problem is that those tools are too few.
                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                  Which is to say, the amplification effect isn't bad, but the bias of the tools of amplification against professionals is harmful.
              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                Only Facebook theoretically includes professional tools of amplification for its network, and even than not really.
            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
              The central thesis is supposedly that gatekeepers are bad, so lets demolish them, but in practice, the results are far different...
          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
            The current structure of social network optimizes for individual citizens, but in doing so it optimizes against expertise.
        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
          Social networks that are built to amplify individuals past gatekeepers also hurt individuals who build expertise not on those networks.
      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
        If you spend all day doing scientific research, you're not well equipped to use amplification tools as well as someone who just does social
    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
      In our original media structure, professional media provided the counterbalance to individual conversations and beliefs.
  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
    In this way, the amplification effects of the water-cooler were balanced by professional media amplifying experts. But balance has broken
    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
      A central methodology of social networks is to amplify humans over organizations. This has continually held true...
      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
        The water-cooler crowd is louder than experts. But also no longer sufficiently amplified, the expert amplification is selected against.
        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
          In other words: the natural form of our modern social networks is anti-intellectual, anti-expert. It promotes--enshrines--this as a method
          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
            We used the wrong metaphor: it isn't just gatekeepers & kept. There's also amplification & amplified. 2 sets intersect but are not the same.
            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
              The media landscape is clearly broken, but a big reason is because, without the capability to amplify experts to the level of your buds...
              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                Social networks force media to become the things your water-cooler amplifies. Expertise has no special tools of amplification
                1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                  So this problem is worth examining from another angle. The solution will never ever be forcing social networks to de-amplify someone.
                  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                    Instead the solution must be to provide additional tools of amplification.
                    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                      We have to find ways to hit information networks harder, outside of their rules we have to build new, modern, tools of mass amplification.
                      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                        These tools can't just be to impact social networks, but that *has* to be part of it, which means:
                        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                          That the needs of media are counter to the primary metaphor of social networks. We can fix them, but they will never help us in our efforts.
                          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                            If you want to know what tools your media co should be building, the answer is: get massive, cheaply. New mass amplification breaks rules.
                            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                              The new tools of mass amplification have to break the rules because the rules are built on bad assumptions. The rules are anti-intellectual.


Search tweets' text