Chronotope’s avatarChronotope’s Twitter Archive—№ 37,831

          1. …in reply to @nickisnixed
            nickisnixed jedpressfate I've actually been thinking about this a lot, is it a conflict on interest? It really depends on the situation...
        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
          nickisnixed jedpressfate The big problem is that the indie community and the AAA community both deal in shared distribution platforms.
      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
        nickisnixed jedpressfate If you were to publish a book with Tor, it would be unethical IMO to review some other Tor book. But...
    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
      nickisnixed jedpressfate ... all games distribute through Steam pretty much. It gives incentive to promote, which could be an ethics issue
  1. …in reply to @Chronotope
    Chronotope jedpressfate JMan240 The big issue is you don't want a revolving door of dev-to-journ-to-dev high-five-ing each other.
    1. …in reply to @Chronotope
      jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed There's clearly some ethical concerns with dev/journos. The game industry is perhaps unique in this...
      1. …in reply to @Chronotope
        jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed ... because, IMO, more reviewers have an interest in making games than in other media criticism.
        1. …in reply to @Chronotope
          jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed Far bigger issues: both press junkets & gifts are considered unethical, but mainstay of games journalism
          1. …in reply to @Chronotope
            jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed The other half of the question is that critics are generally forbidden from being involved in PR tasks.
          2. …in reply to @Chronotope
            jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed But every indie dev does own PR. Would indie film makers fall under Article 5:3? fipresci.org/about/statutes.htm
            1. …in reply to @Chronotope
              jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed Article 6:4 of Film Critics' Fed. bans critics who recently worked in-industry: fipresci.org/about/statutes.htm
              1. …in reply to @Chronotope
                jedpressfate JMan240 nickisnixed Also consider SPJ's rules - spj.org/ethicscode.asp - "Avoid conflicts of interest, real or perceived."


Search tweets' text