-
Now that Facebook is pivoting to video again, I thought it might be useful to go over a rough timeline of the on-again-off-again pivots to video over the last 5+ years...
-
Remember Tronc? " Video, like text before it, is about to explode in supply, and prices are eventually going to drop because much of that video inventory is going to be terrible. We will exaggerate that supply with metrics that aren’t real," blog.jaypinho.com/2016/06/20/video-is-not-your-savior/
-
Measurement bullshit started immediately because of course it did, this is ad tech we're talking about Chronotope/768853585593532416
-
No one surprised when no one wants video jayrosen_nyu/746781771950333952
-
Everyone keeps predicting Video will become the primary method of consuming the web. It didn't. It hasn't. cjr.org/analysis/reuters_report.php
-
And these pivots are never based on what users want anyway. joshtpm/746851693338501121
-
Hell, sometimes there aren't even users watching the videos. Or sometimes your videos are being watched, after being ripped off somewhere else Chronotope/788015864285134848
-
And then oops all the metrics *were* bad after all, real bad Chronotope/819960513920724994
-
"pivot to declining pageviews" macloo/913475109104451585
-
People keep forgetting "Video is the most expensive and time-consuming of the multimedia disciplines." cjr.org/business_of_news/pivot-to-video.php
-
We keep forgetting the lessons of Own Your Platform when it comes to video - jbenton/913386636305715201
-
"publishers should not forget what made their publications great in the first place" newsmediaalliance.org/pivot-to-video/
-
Remember, the bumps in CPM only last for as long as video is rare. When video supply goes up... CPMs go down. "One publisher said its Facebook-monetized videos had an average CPM of 15 cents." digiday.com/media/facebooks-ad-breaks-are-not-bringing-in-a-lot-of-money-for-publishers/
-
As the metrics show themselves to be false, the supply becomes bloated, and the cheap videos become clear for what they are, the ad buyers pull back - “In terms of short-form content buyers, almost everyone we saw two years ago is gone from the market” digiday.com/future-of-tv/healthy-market-digital-video-series-thinned/
-
"There is no evidence consumers want more video, and video production is expensive, logistically difficult, and hard to scale" niemanlab.org/2017/12/r-i-p-pivot-to-video-2017-2017/
-
Remember the messy video fallout at Vice in 2017? asharma/961214212214280192
-
Oops actually the video view stats were *even worse* then the mistaken correction Facebook gave indicated. DaveMilbo/1052422652009345027
-
It's very easy to fake or screw up these numbers and when the numbers do get *screwed up* (intentionally or not) vendors have no incentive to fix it. Chronotope/1052525705739886592
-
It's always journalism that gets sacrificed on the alter of video metrics fakery and BS. charliearchy/1069646411120033792
-
And it isn't like the pivot to video was *ever* a pivot to quality. petersterne/1091563829169922048
-
And the platforms keep BSing each other into bigger and bigger changes towards video without even their own stats being right, to massive and usually terrible effect. dansinker/1136333498841817089
-
But no stopping stupidity I guess Chronotope/1156571531478282243
-
The people who do the work who get punished in these high stress, heavy workload pivots. "Resources were reallocated to video stuff that no one really wanted, and people lost their jobs ... Multiple websites pivoted themselves ... out of existence" hazlitt.net/feature/year-pivoting-video
-
And they kept pivoting themselves out of existence! Chronotope/1214184085637279744
-
But of course the advertisers are just as bad at learning as the publishers. duncanwc/1288802400904478721
-
While we all suffer from the pivot to video it seems like Facebook/Meta is the one who can't keep pivoting. Over and over. mattnavarra/1452929697839566861
-
But no one fixes the actual problems of course. Chronotope/1517120103401275393
-
Facebook / Meta's many Pivots To Video have hurt the media industry badly, and proven useless. But from 2014 adage.com/article/digital/facebook-s-biggest-weapon-youtube-algorithm/294873
-
to today: PopCrave/1551985935687905280
-
Facebook keeps trying to pivot to video, and every time it forces the rest of the media industry along with it. To the detriment of civil society and journalism... but Facebook doesn't feel that hurt or care, so why not keep trying and trying and trying and trying...
-
So yeah, I guess you could say I remain salty too! moorehn/1552276904048295939
-
Maybe publishers will Learn Something this time and not be led by the nose right into the volcano... But I sort of doubt it.
-
The media industry never learns. Chronotope/1089174595003916288